| Category | Excellent | Good | Needs work |
|---|---|---|---|
| Organization & Formatting |
5 All formatting guidelines are followed. |
4 Most formatting guidelines are followed; only one or two components from the template are missing. |
3 Most formatting guidelines are followed; several components from the template are missing or incomplete. |
| Data Analysis |
15 / 14 All analysis requirements are followed, including data cleaning, modeling, and analysis, and all modeling and analysis is correctly specified. Code runs without error and results can be fully reproduced. |
13 / 12 / 11 Most analysis requirements are followed, including data cleaning, modeling, and analysis. There may be some small errors in modeling or interpretation, but these errors do not have a strong effect on outcomes or conclusions. Code might contain a few errors, but the results can still be reproduced with a few fixes. |
10 / 9 / 8 / 7 / 6 / 5 Some of the analysis requirements components are incomplete or missing, including data cleaning, modeling, and analysis. Interpretation or modeling is incorrect or mis-specified, leading to errors in conclusions. Code contains multiple significant errors and results cannot be reproduced, even with efforts to correct errors. |
| Report Contents |
15 / 14 All report guidelines are followed, including the introduction, descriptions of the survey and modeling / analysis, and results and recommendations / conclusions are clear and justified by results. |
13 / 12 / 11 Most report guidelines are followed, including the introduction, descriptions of the survey and modeling / analysis; results and recommendations / conclusions are perhaps unclear or missing important details, but are still largely supported by the modeling results. |
10 / 9 / 8 / 7 / 6 / 5 Several report guidelines are not followed, including the introduction, descriptions of the survey and modeling / analysis; results and recommendations / conclusions are unclear or missing, or are not supported by the modeling results. Some components are incomplete or missing. |
| Appendix |
5 Appendix of the full survey is included. |
4 Appendix of the full survey is included, but some parts of the survey may be missing. |
3 No appendix of survey included |